They’re writing songs of love – but not for me…
So sung Elton John during the opening credits of that iconic film Four Weddings and a Funeral some 32 years ago. You may recall that as the last notes of the song fade away, unlike the other lead characters, whom we have seen breakfasting, dressing and setting off in good time for ‘wedding number one’, the scene focusses on a youthful Hugh Grant’s character Charles, waking up characteristically late, and having to race to avoid a fate that bears some similarity to the bridesmaids in that famous parable from Matthew’s gospel.
Such are the amusing and poignant dramatic twists of that ‘four parts out of five’ romantic comedy, that we see the hapless Charles arrive late for three of the four weddings in a row – his on-time arrival at the fourth one (intended to be his own) being the result of very necessary trickery by his friends… only for this final one not to be completed when he admits that he is not in love with the long-suffering woman standing at the altar. No wonder the movie begins with that Gershwin song proclaiming They’re writing song of love – but not for me!
While the weddings of the movie inevitably take us into the realms of dramatic excess (for, in over thirty years of ministry I have yet to encounter forgotten rings, at my most nervous I have never alluded to the Holy Goat, and I’ve never seen a bride punch a groom in the face), we can still recognize that these amusing settings are still weddings, albeit laced with drama that is a tad exaggerated.
Parables, however, present us with challenges that move beyond the initial setting, and can – and should – cause us some surprise. For only in the world of which Jesus speaks do we learn about labourers working for one hour being paid the same as those who work all day;
only in the world of which Jesus speaks are enormous resources entrusted to slaves to invest;
only in the world of which Jesus speaks does a landlord see his son murdered by rent-avoiding tenants with a substantial history of violence behind them;
only in the world of which Jesus speaks does a shepherd leave 99 vulnerable sheep to go in search of one that is missing;
an only in the world of which Jesus speaks does a loving father give away half of his estate to be squandered before restoring his foolish son with robes, rings and feasts.
And, as we learn this morning, it is only in the world of which Jesus speaks that we see a wedding being so terribly delayed that the celebration begins at midnight, only then to see 50% of the guests being locked out for being only a little bit later themselves.
All of which tells us, that as with the labourers, the slaves, the landlord, the shepherd, and the landed father, Jesus has moved the conversation on from his initial illustration – Jesus has left all these earthly settings and people way behind.
Today, we should realise, Jesus is not really talking about a wedding, but – as he makes explicitly clear – he is talking about the kingdom of heaven – a place where, by the standards of the various kingdoms of this world, some very disconcerting things happen – and, in today’s parable, happen at what we might call the ‘darkest hour’, that scary time when it falls to the people of God to bring light into utter darkness.
And I think there are at least two highly disconcerting elements to this well-known parable. The first is that, rather surprisingly, we seem to be being told that contrary to our upbringing, it is not good to share.
And the second, and even more disconcerting idea – at least for a Christian such as myself, who believes in a God who is inclusive and all-loving – is the notion that God would ‘close the door’ for all eternity on any of God’s beloved and precious children.
All of which make it seem that the foolish young women of this parable have good cause to echo those Gershwin lyrics that lament that They are writing songs of love – but not for me…
And yet, so the author of the Book of Wisdom is at pains to tell his listeners – Wisdom… is easily discerned by those who love her.
The question, of course, is what – really – is the oil of this parable. Given that a few chapters ago Jesus was telling his followers that if someone wants to take your shirt, you should give them your coat as well, why does he now appear to mandate an attitude that is so ungenerous. Surely the wise young women should be giving all of their oil to the foolish, rather than refusing to share altogether?
Which means – of course – that the ‘oil’ of this taxing parable represents something that it is not possible to share… that it is not an ‘asset’ that could be mine or yours… that it is not something that could be taken from me by force, or which I could give to you out of generosity. It means, surely, that this precious ‘oil’ at the heart of this parable is nothing less than love (as many commentators have come to realize over at least 1600 years, going back to no less an authority than St Augustine).
For while I can model love for someone else to imitate – while I can demonstrate good ways of behaving and hope my life becomes a great example for others – I cannot share, sell or give this to anyone else… because I cannot love on your behalf. For love is not an asset or commodity to be traded, and we can, I think, only regard as an example of irony the suggestion from the wise that the foolish should go and purchase the necessary oil – noting that a parable makes one specific point, and that you should not expect every detail of it to map across to real life situations.
Once we begin to get the true nature of the oil in this story, the rest starts to fall in place, helped by some of the nuances in the original Greek which might help us expand or interpret what is really happening here. For the foolish bridesmaids believe they simply need to be let in – they do not understand that they cannot be admitted into a community of love if they do not, if they will not, live out that love themselves.
For God can kindle love in us, God can nourish love, God can help transform our capacity to love – but God cannot make us love – which is why, ultimately, God chooses to model love, even to the very point of death.
And thus, when we hear the bridegroom’s chilling response, he is not just saying that he doesn’t know these hapless women… we should perhaps hear the response as implying God does not understand their demand to come in, for God does not recognize the presence of love in their lives, for God sees how they have turned their backs on love.
For Wisdom… is easily discerned by those who love her. But if you have, indeed, turned your back on love, you won’t find it easy to discern wisdom either, for in Scripture the two are intimately connected.
Or, to misquote Ira Gershwin, They’re writing songs of love… but I’m ignoring them.
In short, this parable is as much about the choices we make in living our lives, as it is about any choice which God makes… which is why it is a deeply appropriate backdrop for Remembrance Sunday – a day when we recall across too many decades what happened when the light faded, when wisdom fell into short supply, and when the presence of the bridegroom felt very long delayed.
I think it highly probable, in as much as the word would have made sense in the context of the world two thousand years ago, that Jesus was a pacifist. And there can be no doubt that war is sinful, and I am certain that God looks at the battlefields of the world and weeps.
But in this life darkness does fall, and the power of sin sometimes confronts God’s children in the starkest of ways – and we should never forget that in deep darkness, even the smallest light – even the smallest amount of oil – can make an enormous difference.
Delivering yesterday’s Thought for the Day, Lucy Winkett, the Rector of St James’ Church on Piccadilly, remarked very powerfully, “A profound paradox is that the perversion and trauma of war is also the context for the very best of humanity to emerge… In war we understand more deeply our capacity not just for betrayal but for honour – not just for hostility but for sacrifice.”
Or, to put it even more simply, God has been writing songs of love… even for me and for you – writing them through all eternity. Let’s pray that, on this day of such profound remembrance, we are able to open our ears and our hearts and hear them once again. For, in truth, Wisdom… is easily discerned by those who love her.
Amen.
Stay up to date with York Minster
- Event alerts
- Seasonal services
- Behind the scenes features
- Latest Minster-inspired gifts