“See what love the Father has given us, that we should be called children of God; and that is what we are.”
Some of the people who brought us here this morning are no longer with us. Some of the people who brought us here this morning have never set foot in this building. Some of the people who brought us here this morning are people we would rather forget.
Yet each of these people are present in the people we have become.
The people who taught us to speak. The people who taught us how to relate. The people whose kindness gave us courage to carry on. The people whose words still inhabit our thoughts. Even the people who have wounded us may remain painfully present in the way we understand and present ourselves.
We like to believe in the myth that our lives belong entirely to us. That we are the authors of our own identities. But what that is one of the great illusions of being human. What if the person you call yourself and I call myself, has never actually existed independently of other people?
This is not merely a psychological observation. It draws us towards something extraordinary about the nature of God, and to the very heart of what we celebrate on All Saints’ Day.
We tend to think that first there is the individual, and then the relationships that individual chooses to form. I exist; and then, I encounter you. But is that how a person really comes into being?
For none of us arrived as a fully independent self. We were first received, held, fed and taught. We learnt language from others; even the words with which we understand ourselves came to us as gifts. Our identities were formed and shaped through relationships we never chose.
Philosophers sometimes speak of the autonomous self: the idea that we possess an identity entirely independent of others. Yet, however much this ideal seeks to safeguard personal freedom, it fails to account for a fundamental truth about what it means to be human: none of us becomes who we are in isolation. We become who we are through our dependence on others.
For dependence is not a regrettable stage on the way to becoming fully human. It is a vital part of what it actually means to be fully human.
And Christianity takes this theme and then runs with it. Our relational nature is not understood merely as some biological accident. It discloses for us something about the very nature of God.
In a few moments, we will profess our faith in God as Father, Son and Holy Spirit. The Trinity is not an awkward piece of divine arithmetic. It reveals something fundamental about the very nature of God: that love, relationship and communion belong eternally to God’s own life. God does not need someone else to love in order to become loving. Love is not simply something God does; it is who God is. And within the life of the Trinity, distinction does not threaten unity, nor does unity erase distinction. To be distinct and to be in communion are not mere opposites, they belong inseparably together.
If we therefore are made in God’s image and likeness, then we become more fully ourselves not by escaping dependence, but by fully embracing it, learning how to give and receive love without ever seeking to possess or diminish one another.
It also reveals the meaning of sainthood. We imagine saints as exceptionally accomplished individuals: the spiritually strong, the morally heroic, those who have climbed higher than the rest of us. Yet John in today’s first reading writes: “See what love the Father has given us, that we should be called children of God; and that is what we are.” Not what we have earned. What we have been given. Holiness does not earn us God’s love; we pursue holiness because God loved us first.
But how does that gift change us? How does our God-given identity transform the way we encounter one another?
Here the Beatitudes are essential. John shows that holiness begins in God’s unearned love; Jesus shows how that love takes shape in the complexity and vulnerability of our relationships.
The Beatitudes are not steps by which exceptional people ascend to God. The Beatitudes depict lives open to the needs of others rather than guarded by self-interest.
Mercy begins when another’s suffering lays a claim to us. Peace-making requires the hard work of healing relationships fractured by fear or hatred. Mourning shows that love has exposed us to loss. To hunger for righteousness is to recognise our privilege and refuse to separate our wellbeing from the dignity of others.
These are not simply the private accomplishments of admirable individuals. They describe lives that have ceased to regard other people as incidental.
But we must be careful. What Jesus is not doing is blessing poverty because deprivation is good, or persecution because suffering makes people holy. What Jesus is announcing is that those whom the world dismisses are not beyond the reach of God’s blessing.
This is why the communion of saint’s matters.
The ancient phrase communio sanctorum can mean both the fellowship of holy people and participation in holy things. The two belong together. We are made a people by sharing in a life we did not create.
Baptism does not enrol us among successful believers. Baptism incorporates us into the Body of Christ. At the Eucharist we do not seek private portions of grace. We receive from the one bread, discovering that belonging to Christ binds us to people we might otherwise have never chosen.
All of which sounds wonderful until we remember how easily the Church can corrupt the language of communion.
We can use the language of unity to demand silence, loyalty to excuse wrongdoing, and belonging to pressure people into concealing their wounds. We can mistake the absence of disagreement for the presence of love. But communion is not conformity.
If God’s own life is communion without the abolition of distinction, the Church cannot make uniformity a condition of belonging. Genuine communion is capable of hearing unwelcome truths. It does not demand that those who have been harmed sacrifice justice for the appearance of peace.
Sometimes the most saintly person in a community is the one who interrupts its comfortable harmony and asks whose voice has been excluded. Which is a demanding thought in a building filled with memorials to centuries of Christian devotion. We rightly honour what has been handed down. But fidelity to the saints cannot mean preserving everything exactly as they left it. They too were called to encounter the God who unsettles, forgives and changes us.
And the Feast of All Saints is not only about those whose names appear in calendars or whose likenesses adorn these walls. It is about people who cared without being thanked, who showed mercy when nobody was watching, who remained faithful without knowing whether their efforts made any difference. People through whom others discovered that their lives mattered.
And that makes a claim upon this place. We may sing of saints, commemorate saints and carve saints in stone. But if someone enters this Minster and finds their suffering inconvenient, their difference unwelcome or their voice too uncomfortable to hear, we will have celebrated All Saints without having understood it.
For the test of communion is not how warmly we honour those who have gone before us. It is whether we are willing to be changed by those whom God has placed beside us. Whose suffering are we prepared to let interrupt our lives? Whose dignity will we defend? Whose truth will we hear, even when it costs us our comfort?
We began with those who shaped us. We leave asking whom our lives might console, embolden or liberate. For Christ makes saints by drawing us into God’s own life of love, never away from the human condition. That love refuses to dismiss suffering, diminish dignity or deny belonging. We cannot celebrate the communion of saints while choosing who deserves our communion. For when we refuse those whom Christ welcomes, we refuse Christ himself.
Amen.
Stay up to date with York Minster
- Event alerts
- Seasonal services
- Behind the scenes features
- Latest Minster-inspired gifts